Advertisement

'I think the window was honestly a solid 8 out of 10'

Your view banner
[BBC]
Maksym Talovierov and Nikola Katic about to shake hands on the pitch.
[Getty Images]

We asked you for your views on Plymouth Argyle's winter transfer window dealings.

Generally, the theme was positive, especially the additions of Maksym Talovierov, Tymoteusz Puchacz and Nikola Katic in defence, as the club twice broke its record for a fee paid and also received a club record £5m plus add-ons for Morgan Whittaker.

Will it be enough for Miron Muslic's side to beat the drop?

Here is a selection of what Pilgrims fans had to say...

Terry: It is lovely to see that Argyle have purchased players with some credible skills. The loan market has been good to us, but I felt the last group didn't have the heart nor courage to truly excel in the Championship. With players being brought in, they all have so much to prove, and with their respective personal statuses, they should be cementing their places in the team and showing other clubs what they are capable of.

Moose: Good signings! We trust the management and these players to do their very best to keep us up or, if not, to return us to the Championship at the first time of asking.

Chezzbo: Complete and utter disgrace. Waiting in anticipation just for the window to open, never mind to keep up with our business during it. We needed essentially a new team of players. Sold our best defender and attacker and didn't put that money back into the team like we needed. An extreme gamble from the higher-ups, and if we do end up going down, we know whose fault it is.

Matthew: I think the window was honestly a solid 8 out of 10. Players in and some senior players out. Whittaker and Gibson were big losses, but the money should help plug the leaky defence.

Keith: First impressions of Talovierov, Katic and Puchacz are excellent, and maybe bringing in Boateng will allow Randell to support the attack more.

Michael Baidoo in action.
[Rex Features]

Ricardo: A big change of style and a bit early to tell, but Miron seems to have a positive but realistic approach, and the signings look good. I'm still optimistic about staying up but could accept the alternative as long as we go down fighting.

Chris: Honestly, think we have done well on the defensive side, so hopefully we can stop leaking goals, which will make us harder to beat, but my concern is not getting another attacker, as you can defend well, but you still need to score goals.

Steve: Good business, and great to see the new manager shoring up our weak defence. If this works, we have a chance of staying up!

Roger: There are signs the Muslic strategy is having an effect. There is still time to gather enough points to beat the drop, but a lot of catching up to do. The key will be beating the clubs we face in the bottom half, but the last two performances will have given the players a huge lift.

David: Time will tell, but I think we have done well. We have certainly strengthened the defence. A striker would have been nice; hopefully we have enough goals in the team to keep us up.

Pad: You've got to roll the dice. Hopefully they will have the desired effect. The Great Escape is on....