'Are you serious?': Fans blow up over shock Dally M snubs

Angry NRL fans are calling for a “huge overhaul” of the Dally M voting system after a number of dubious awards.

While Roger Tuivasa-Sheck was no doubt a deserving winner of the player of the year award, just pipping Kalyn Ponga in the final round of voting, there was a moment that left fans stunned.

As the Dally M team of the year was announced a couple of decisions were dubious at best, especially considering the calibre of player that missed out.

Most of the conjecture centred around rocks and diamonds Canberra centre Joseph Leilua and tough Bulldogs captain Josh Jackson.

Leilua beat out fan favourite Latrell Mitchell in the centre race, stunning many onlookers in the wake of the Roosters centre’s blockbuster season.

However with individual positions decided by overall Dally M points and Leilua occasionally the best player on the park for the Raiders, despite not being as consistent as Mitchell, the decision went to the Canberra wrecking ball.

Jackson’s selection was just as controversial, as the tough second-rower beat out the likes of Viliame Kikau, Tariq Sims and Tyson Frizell.

Most fans couldn’t believe Panthers beast Kikau was snubbed, despite a breakout season in which he consistently ruined opposition defensive lines.

Working in Leilua and Jackson’s favour was the voting system that favours players from less-successful teams with fewer star teammates to fight with for 3-2-1 points.

On the other hand, Mitchell and Kikau were constantly competing for points with representative stars such as James Tedesco, Cooper Cronk and Nathan Cleary.

Angry and confused fans took to Twitter to share their shock and disbelief at the decisions.

Tuivasa-Sheck wins Dally M player of year

Roger Tuivasa-Sheck has become the first Warrior to win the Dally M medal as the Kiwi fullback heralded a new generation of talent in the NRL.

Tuivasa-Sheck polled 29 votes to win the league’s player-of-the-season award by two points from Newcastle’s Kalyn Ponga, with Cronulla’s Valentine Holmes in third.

In a sign of the changing times, none of the top five – which also included Luke Brooks and Mitchell Pearce – have previously polled in the top five positions at the Dally Ms during their career.

The Warriors fullback trailed by one vote with a round to go, but polled three points in the final round against Canberra while Ponga remained on the sideline injured.

In doing so, he became the first fullback to win the award since Ben Barba in 2012, as he averaged 167 metres a match and busted through a total of 92 tackles.

He was presented the award by Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Johnathan Thurston, before Issac Luke, Jazz Tevaga, Jamayne Isaako and Jordan Rapana launched an impromptu haka.

“I’m just blown away to be up here holding this award,” Tuivasa-Sheck said.

“It’s crazy the generation that is coming through. Damien Cook, Valentine Holmes, Kalyn Ponga and Luke Brooks still real young and being mentioned up there.

“It’s an exciting year for rugby league and exciting for what’s yet to come.”

Meanwhile Pearce’s effort to finish fifth – and just six points off the pace – in his first year at Newcastle is most impressive considering he missed nine games through injury in the middle of the season.

In other awards, Melbourne skipper Cameron Smith won captain of the year, South Sydney’s Anthony Seibold was coach of the year and Brisbane’s Isaako was the rookie of the year after leading the point-scoring race.

Symbolic of the closest competition in the NRL’s history, no club had more than one starting player in the Dally M team of the year.

Sunday’s grand finalists Melbourne and the Sydney Roosters both had one pick, with Cameron Munster at five-eighth and Blake Ferguson as winger.

Meanwhile South Sydney’s Damien Cook picked up both the Dally M hooker of the year award and the Provan Summons people’s choice medal.

Brisbane’s Brittany Breayley was the NRL women’s player of the competition, while Gold Coast captain Ryan James won the Ken Stephen medal for his community work.

DALLY M CLASS OF 2018

Dally M, Fullback: Roger Tuivasa-Sheck (Warriors)

Captain: Cameron Smith (Storm)

Coach: Anthony Seibold (South Sydney Rabbitohs)

Winger: Blake Ferguson (Roosters)

Centre: Joseph Leilua (Raiders)

Five-eighth: Cameron Munster (Storm)

Halfback: Luke Brooks (Wests Tigers)

Lock: Jason Taumalolo (Cowboys)

Second-rower: Josh Jackson (Bulldogs)

Prop: Andrew Fifita (Sharks)

Hooker, Provan Summons People’s Choice: Damien Cook (Rabbitohs)

Interchange: Jazz Tevaga (Warriors)

Rookie, top pointscore: Jamayne Isaako (Broncos)

Top tryscorer: David Fusitu’a (Warriors)

Female player: Brittany Breayley (Broncos)

Ken Stephen medal: Ryan James (Titans)

With AAP