Rugby League fans erupt over 'awful' World Cup call: 'Robbed'
Rugby league great James Graham has led the disbelief after Papua New Guinea were disallowed a try against Tonga after a controversial tackle in a thrilling 24-18 loss at the World Cup.
In the closest game of the tournament so far, Tonga had to wait until the 78th minute for South Sydney's Keaon Koloamatangi, who played a lengthy stint at hooker, to touch down.
OUCH: James Tedesco incident sparks million-dollar World Cup warning
HUGE: Schuster footage that will shock NRL fans amid dramas at Manly
The Kumuls, whose hooker Edwin Ipape was named man of the match, could have felt hard done by to have not emerged with the two points after holding their gloves up against a star-studded Tongan side.
And the controversial moment came in the 53rd minute when Tonga were leading PNG 18-12.
Melbourne Storm's Justin Olam dived towards the try line as Tonga's Tolu Koula collected the winger with a brutal hit and sent him crashing into the corner post.
Koula's tackle was controversial as there appeared little attempt to wrap his arm around Olam.
There was debate on whether Olam had placed the ball down first, before heading out of play.
"This is a try Vossy," Graham said looking at the replays.
However, the video referee had deemed the ball had touched the sideline and confirmed a No Try.
The drama wasn't over.
The Rugby League world, including former England forward Graham, couldn't believe the video referee wasn't checking the shoulder charge.
"He never even looked at the tackle," commentator Andrew Voss said in disbelief.
I’m not sure what’s worst about this. @AndrewVossy @RLWC2021
1. Given as a no try.
2. The blatant shoulder charge.
3. James Graham’s accent pic.twitter.com/uZdt96PQ9W— What would Brian Bevan say? 🇺🇦🎙🎧 (@WhatBevan) October 18, 2022
"Wow. By the letter of the law he does not attempt to wrap his arm around the attacker," Graham added.
Rugby League world erupts over PNG No Try
Many in the rugby league world agreed with both Voss and Graham that the shoulder charge needed to be looked at during the replay.
Others suggested the 'shoulder charge' stopped a certain try and an eight point try should have been awarded.
Not quite sure how the video ref has called that as a No Try, and if it is no try then it’s a penalty try surely for a shoulder charge? Absolutely baffling decision #RLWC2021
— David Jagger (@davejagger) October 18, 2022
Was a blatant shoulder charge & they didn't even look at it. The 1st game that's had all English Offials & they make a blunder like that 🙄
— Dean 'The Phenomenal Adonis' (@BrolyAdonisDC) October 18, 2022
Shows the standard of our officials! 💩💩💩
If its not a try, it was a definite shoulder charge and therefore a penalty try!— Gareth 💙💙💙 (@garethmonkey) October 18, 2022
Its not a shoulder charge because he uses his arm in the tackle but it is a try because he gets the ball down. pic.twitter.com/YJJhfXQSWz
— Brad Boucher (@WePlayLeague) October 18, 2022
PNG robbed! Perfect try disallowed there and no mention of the shoulder charge!? Can't have #Tonga embarrassed can we? #RLWC2022 #RLWC21
— MaggieMartyn (@maggie_martyn) October 18, 2022
That’s shocking refereeing #rlwc2021 if it’s not a try, it’s a penalty for the shoulder charge!
— Bekki Workman (@bworkman1990) October 18, 2022
100% not a regular try... but a penalty try surely? Only stops him with a shoulder charge
— OffBeat RL (@BizarreRl) October 18, 2022
Probably right result overall but definitely a dud call on a disallowed try mate. Shoulder charge bit like Billy Slater a few years back in the simi final
— Jamie Waterhouse (@Jamiewaterhous1) October 18, 2022
That’s ridiculous. No evidence it hit touch in goal. If that’s not a try, then the video process is flawed. Absolute shite.
— RichdelaRiviere (@RichdelaRiviere) October 18, 2022
Terrible decision in the Tonga PNG game. Not only was it a try but, even if it wasn't, a penalty try should have been awarded for a shoulder charge. #RLWC2021
— Martin Ingram (@air_ingy) October 18, 2022
That’s a try all day long, and a shoulder charge to go with it, more awful officiating from English refs
— jordan mattinson (@jordanmattins10) October 18, 2022
Despite the controversial incident, PNG put in a stoic performance against the heavy hitting Tongans in front of 10,409 fans at the Totally Wicked Stadium.
PNG, who were $12 outsiders, had begun ominously when skipper Rhys Martin scored after six minutes.
Winger Daniel Russell, who was a late inclusion for Xavier Coates, was unlucky to not have not followed him over the line twice.
Tonga were under the pump and a Will Penisini try against the run of play sparked the small legion of fans decked out in red into a frenzy.
Moeaki Fotuaika and Isaiya Katoa both crossed off the back of long-range tries to put Tonga back in control with an 18-6 lead at halftime.
But PNG came out firing with Ipape sending haflback Lachlan Lam over straight after the break.
And despite having a try for winger Rodrick Tai chalked off, the Kumuls kept pushing and they got their reward when Toulatau Koula knocked on at a play-the-ball on the Tonga line.
PNG struck and after being denied twice earlier, Russell made no mistake with his third attempt, going over off a set play from a scrum.
Martin converted to square the game up at 18-18.
Katoa missed the chance to put Tonga ahead up with a 75th-minute penalty but to his relief his side didn't need it.
Pushing for a late try, the ball went through eight sets of hands, hit the ground four times before Siosiua Taukeiaho grubber kicked through for Koloamatangi to touch down.
with AAP
Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.