NRL boss' shocking admission after Tigers and Dragons dudded in 'disgraceful' drama
Graham Annesley has conceded there were three incorrect calls that cost teams in round 23.
NRL head of football Graham Annesley has admitted the Wests Tigers, Dragons and Dolphins were all on the receiving end of incorrect refereeing calls in their respective losses last weekend. Fans flocked to social media in disgust after a number of controversial calls proved costly for the NRL strugglers. A number of questionable refereeing decisions have come under fire over a chaotic weekend that saw two players sent off and a number of sin-binnings dished out across the eight games.
The standard of officiating in the NRL was again put under the microscope on Sunday as the last-placed Tigers went down to the Canberra Raiders in a 22-18 heartbreaker, while fellow strugglers the Dragons were overrun by the fast-finishing Parramatta Eels, who prevailed 20-10. Both games were dogged by controversy, with the Tigers fuming after the Raiders scored off an apparent forward pass and the Dragons seething over a knock-on call against Jacob Liddle they thought should have been awarded a try.
'GAVE UP': Latrell Mitchell in firing line after incident against Sharks
'RIDICULOUS': Fans up in arms over sin bin drama as Burgess banned
An irate Tigers coach Tim Sheens claimed in his post-match press conference that Canberra actually scored off two forward pass tries - both involving Jack Wighton. The first was perhaps lineball but the second looked more obvious as the ball came out of the five-eighth's hands forwards, before bouncing even further forward into the arms of teammate Sebastian Kris, who raced away to score a crucial try.
That was special from Sebastian Kris, but was the pass forward?
📺 Watch #NRLRaidersTigers on ch.502 or stream on Kayo: https://t.co/B1ijnGXtqA
✍️ BLOG https://t.co/lpkZRDubNF
🔢 MATCH CENTRE https://t.co/seRnWLRuyj pic.twitter.com/oLaw8x77eI— Fox League (@FOXNRL) August 6, 2023
“I was pretty disappointed with a few of the decisions. I’ve got to congratulate Rick for coaching a side that didn’t give away one extra set of six, according to our statistician, so very good coaching,” Sheens said sarcastically.
“The first try I was a bit disappointed, I feel there was a forward pass in that try. There were a couple, there was one in the second half and the first try, that lead up pass, looking at it I was pretty unhappy with that so that’s something I’ll take up with the referees as I do every week."
On Monday afternoon, Annesley agreed with Sheens' assessment of Kris's second try. "As Jack Wighton passes this ball, if you look at the motion of the hands it appears to be forward," Annesley said as he described the pass in his weekly briefing at NRL headquarters.
"You can see the touch judge at the bottom of the screen who is pretty much in line with this ... looking at this one with the camera on the halfway line, I don't think you can reach much other conclusion than this was a forward pass."
Dragons dudded as fans slam 'disgraceful' refereeing calls
Dragons interim coach Ryan Carr was also seething over an incident that proved costly for his side against Parramatta. Dragons hooker Liddle was deemed to have knocked-on when Eels fullback Clint Gutherson appeared to strip the ball out of his hands, before Junior Amone scooped up the loose ball and planted it over the tryline.
The try would have helped the Dragons jump out to a 26-10 lead, but after being sent to the bunker as a 'no try', the officials ruled it a loose carry and therefore a knock-on from the Dragons. The Eels compounded the visitors' frustrations after staging a second half comeback to win 26-20, leaving Carr fuming and fans up in arms over the incidents from both games.
Watch Gutherson here - tackles Ravalawa inside the 10, doesn't get to marker, and never touches the try line before making the strip/tackle
That's a penalty try @NRL - fix your bunker!#NRLEelsDragons pic.twitter.com/exlzqagu0g— Archie (@archibaldfoley) August 6, 2023
"You google 'strip' and it's hand on the ball, he strips it out. It's play on. It's a try every day of the week," Carr said. "It's ridiculous. If I say 'ridiculous', I'll probably get memed again but that's all right, that's all good.
"Maybe they (the match officials) have to come down and sit here and answer you guys (the media). I have to do a press conference, you ask me. I don't know the answer, so maybe they should come down and sit here and answer the questions for you so everyone in the whole world can understand why that wasn't a try."
Annesley once again admitted that the officials got it wrong. "When you look at this closely, Gutherson is trying to make a tackle, there's no question about that," he said.
"You can see the (Gutherson's) fingers curl up on top of the ball and there is a raking motion that dislodges the ball. The action of Gutherson raking the ball and dispossessing Liddle means the tackle count should have restarted and that should have been a try."
And Annesley also conceded referee Grant Atkins wrongly pinged Dolphins prop Herman Ese'ese for holding a Newcastle player at a scrum late in their match, won 30-28 by the Knights. "Given where the ball goes and the fact no one is prevented from making that tackle and the defensive line would have time to reset, I think that's a very harsh penalty," Annesley said.
@NRL_Dragons Ryan Carr you legend work hard and defending the boys against some disgraceful refereeing. You and the team should be proud, and the @nrl ashamed of themselves
— Benny (@saintbenny63) August 6, 2023
Dragons were terrible in the second. The man of the match should go to the bunker because that "no strip" call by Gutho was the real game changer 💀 #NRLEelsDragons
— Oddski 🏁 (@Odd1x) August 6, 2023
Dragons having that try disallowed changed the momentum.
Gutho raked at the ball, should have been play on— Pauly don't play that (@MrSonicPauly) August 6, 2023
A referee’s job is hard enough without having the assistants creating mayhem through incompetence. The touch judges today may as well have been sitting at home or the nearest pub for all the effort they put in. #disgraceful. #NRLRaidersTigers
— Mac on tap 💉x5 🌎 🇺🇦 (@LetSleepingDogz) August 6, 2023
All of 3 of the Raiders tries have had a forward pass either during the play or in the play before the try was scored. They definitely arent the best team in the comp but the Tigers are getting reamed by the officials today.#NRLRaidersTigers
— 💧PashaBulka (@PashaBulka) August 6, 2023
Blatant forward pass in the lead up to the raiders second try. Not good enough in defending our own line in any case. The moment some resilience is required, we crumble.
Attacking inside the red zone shows exactly why we need a general. Last tackle options are rushed and poor— Brenden (@brendenfingers) August 6, 2023
Raiders with all these forward passes & ref never blows the whistle. #NRLRaidersTigers
— The Thanks I Get (@thethnksiget) August 6, 2023
Thanks to the officials missing 2 forward passes the raiders win. Disgusting
— Joseph Alafaci (@jalafaci) August 6, 2023
with AAP
Sign up to our newsletter and score the biggest sport stories of the week.