The NRL All-Stars anthem furore that's divided fans
A fierce debate has raged on social media after players from the Indigenous team decided not to sing the national anthem during Friday night’s NRL All-Stars match.
The Indigenous All-Stars team proved pace can beat power as they raced in seven tries to storm to a 34-14 win over New Zealand Maori in Melbourne.
While the healthy crowd embraced both teams there was a notable dip in volume when the Australian national anthem was played with a number of players not singing.
Much like the celebration of Australia Day in the country, the national anthem is often a divisive issue for Indigenous Australians and another symbol of the colonisation of the country by European settlers.
Viewers debated why the NRL went ahead with the national anthem considering it was a celebration of Indigenous cultures – both in Australia and New Zealand
Indigenous skipper Cody Walker said post-match that he wasn’t comfortable with it being played at the game.
“To be honest no (it shouldn’t be played) – it just brings back so many memories from what’s happened and I think everyone in Australia needs to get together and work something out,” he said.
“It doesn’t represent me and my family.”
The apparent boycott of the anthem from Indigenous players certainly sparked a heated discussion for fans on social media.
Ok it was a great intro of both war cries BUT the maoris won this IMO. Disappointed that most of the Indigenous players refused to sing the Australian anthem. Embrace #Australia as a great nation! #NRLAllStars
— Roberto (@Roberto_ROC181) February 15, 2019
The whole point of the indigenous all stars match & I quote Preston Campbell "we should be able to move forward" "celebrate who we are" "what makes us beautiful". I don't like our anthem BUT to stand there and not sing, is a step backwards. #NRLAllStars #NRL #Indigenous @FOXNRL
— BradC1982 (@BradC1982) February 15, 2019
#NRL All for the passion. Fantastic. But why only 5 indigenous players sang the anthem…#NRLAllStars
If you don’t like the anthem and it’s words… don’t accept anything that the country of the anthem provides— Scotty Rub (@ScottyRub) February 15, 2019
I’m so proud of the Aboriginal team during the #NRLAllStars game anthem. Advance Australia Fair was written during a time the indigenous weren’t even considered humans. Why should they sing a song that does not represent them? @NRL
— teddyfinch (@teddyfinch) February 15, 2019
Excuse my ignorance, but what is “the indigenous song”? The Australian anthem is supposed to unite everybody that considers themselves an Australian.
— Zeta Ridiculi (@ZetaRid) February 15, 2019
Surely they could have had an indigenous song though as well as the anthem after
— Pat 🐉 (@LeFIash) February 15, 2019
Why didnt the indigenous boys sing the anthem
Hmmmm
— WTF*** (@TheWerris) February 15, 2019
@NRL
Why on earth would you sing the commonwealth-based Aussie anthem in an indigenous game…Most awkward and bizarre thing I've seen in a footy match yet lol#NRLAllStars
— Pat 🐉 (@LeFIash) February 15, 2019
It’s very clear to me why Indigenous people wouldn’t and won’t sing the national anthem. I don’t. They’re not disrespecting the anthem though so why is it an issue? #NRLAllStars
— Bizzi Lavelle (@BizziLavellex) February 15, 2019
can't believe some people are taking offense in regards to many of the indigenous boys choosing not to sing the anthem. i don't even understand why it was sung in the first place? #NRLAllStars
— Emily Simpson (@emcsimpson) February 15, 2019
Just let them do the war dances. Making the Indigenous team stand for an Anthem talking about making Australia fair is a bit cringeworthy
— Kris Read (@DesignedToFade) February 15, 2019
The fact that the New Zealand Maori players sang their own anthem with such gusto merely added fuel to the fire, however, it sparked more commentary from fans that maybe it’s time for Australia to follow our Kiwi neighbours’ lead and incorporate an Indigenous verse into our own anthem.
Would love our Australian anthem to have a verse in one of our indigenous languages #NRLAllStars
— Nat ❤️💚 (@natsaville) February 15, 2019
As a non indigenous Aust am embarrassed Oz anthem in English only whilst NZ anthem both Maori and English. #INDIGENOUS #rugbyleague
— MattyH (@MattHeysmand) February 15, 2019
I agree with the sentiment (NZ anthem is stirring), however there is one Maori language (w/many dialects), but 100s of Indigenous Australian languages.
— highly evolved amoeba (@refriednoodle) February 15, 2019
I can't wait for Australia to follow #NewZealands lead and alter the national anthem to include one form of Indigenous language in our anthem #NRLAllStars
— Mark Mansour (@MarkMansour01) February 15, 2019
Before the first whistle the teams opened with a spine-tingling display with the Maori delivering a fearsome Haka before the Indigenous team responded.
With Latrell Mitchell leading the war cry in the absence of the injured Greg Inglis, the Sydney Roosters centre popped up in a team circle and then danced them down the field to within a metre of the approaching Maori team.
Indigenous speed too hot for Maori men to handle
Much was made of the Maori team’s big men but they had no answer to the blistering speed of some of the Indigenous players in front of almost 19,000 at AAMI Park.
Not even rising superstar Kalyn Ponga could stop the Indigenous onslaught and showed he has plenty of work ahead to feel comfortable in his new role as five-eighth.
“We controlled the ball and the guys executed their skill the way we wanted them to,” Indigenous coach Laurie Daley said.
“We put on some nice plays and scored some nice tries and that was what we wanted to do.”
Local hero Storm winger Josh Addo-Carr led the way early with two tries within three minutes in the first half to take a 10-6 lead.
Parramatta recruit Blake Ferguson was another to get some try-scoring action in the first half and celebrated with a somersault that would have put his new coach Brad Arthur on edge.
Arthur would have been happier to see the ex-Roosters winger, who broke his leg in last year’s grand final, in full flight after taking an intercept although he was run down after a 70m dash.
The Indigenous team led 20-10 at the main break with the pick of the first half tries scored by the Eels’ Bevan French, who came into the side to replace sacked Cowboy Ben Barba.
New Knight Jesse Ramien made a 35m break and kicked a further 35m down-field with French winning the race to the ball.
The Maori’s first-half tries were both scored by Dane Gagai, who became the first player to turn out for both the Indigenous and Maori teams.
Maori coach Stacey Jones said they were simply outplayed by the Indigenous team.
“We’re disappointed … they’ve got class and speed out wide and they just put too much pressure on us,” Jones said.
With AAP