'Disgraceful': League world divided over 'dangerous' Nathan Cleary act

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
·5-min read
In this article:
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
Pictured here, the lifting tackle that threatens to rule Nathan Cleary out of the NRL grand final.
Nathan Cleary could be in strife for a lifting tackle on Melbourne's Jesse Bromwich. Pic: Getty

Penrith star Nathan Cleary faces a nervous wait to be cleared to play in the NRL grand final after being placed on report for a lifting tackle in the 10-6 preliminary final win over the Melbourne Storm on Saturday afternoon.

The Panthers booked their spot in Sunday week's decider against South Sydney after a brutal battle against the minor premiers at Suncorp Stadium.

'IT'S A JOKE': Fans up in arms over Storm concussion 'disgrace'

'UTTER DISGRACE': NRL world up in arms over 'sickening' incident

'ABSOLUTELY MAD': Fans divided as Billy Slater named QLD coach

However, the Panthers will be sweating on Cleary's availability after the halfback's lifting tackle on the Storm’s Kenny Bromwich was placed on report.

Cleary was deemed to be at fault in the tackle alongside teammate Paul Momirovski, with the back of Bromwich's head hitting the turf as the Penrith pair drove him into the ground.

“That is a dangerous tackle, this is drama, this is Cleary,” Andrew Voss said in commentary for Fox League.

“A dangerous tackle has up-ended Kenny Bromwich. That is one absolutely on report and one for the match review committee.

“Mark it down 21st minute. This is a controversial moment in the game.”

However, fellow Fox Sports commentator Michael Ennis said he didn't think there was much in it, insisting it was not bad enough to wipe Cleary out of the NRL decider.

"You can’t miss a grand final for that," Ennis said.

The incident proved particularly divisive for fans on social media, with many agreeing with Ennis' view that it did not warrant a grand final suspension.

Others cited a similar incident involving South Sydney's Isaac Luke in 2014 - that rubbed the hooker out of that year's grand final against Canterbury - as proof that Cleary deserved a ban.

Panthers' coach Ivan Cleary had another halves concern moments later when Jerome Luai left the field after copping a stray Cameron Munster arm to the back of his head following a linebreak.

The Panthers were livid when Munster escaped unpenalised as a groggy Luai left the field, but the Penrith five-eighth returned after the halftime break to play out the game.

Penrith exact 2020 grand final revenge 

Tipped to be under the cosh against well-rested defending champions and minor premiers Melbourne, the battle-hardened Panthers' flipped the script from the outset as they exacted revenge for last year's grand final defeat.

A heads-up kick from dummy half by Cleary found an unmarked Stephen Crichton out wide to score untouched in the second minute and leave the Storm rattled.

Shortly after that Storm prop Christian Welch left the field following an earlier collision with Matt Burton, the Queensland State of Origin star subsequently being ruled out of the game after failing his HIA.

Melbourne were down to just two players on the interchange bench by mid-point of the half when Brandon Smith also came off with a HIA as well as a shoulder issue.

The hooker was also subsequently ruled out by medical staff, putting huge pressure on the Storm's remaining 15 players.

Pictured here, Christian Welch sits on the sideline after failing his HIA.
Christian Welch was one of two early HIA casualties for the Storm. Pic: Fox Sports

The Panthers clearly came with a plan and rattled Melbourne with stirring defence as the Storm finished with a plethora of uncharacteristic errors.

Some of those were especially costly with George Jennings and Reimis Smith both dropping the ball as the Storm threatened the tryline.

Some sensational Panthers' defence also kept the Storm out in the opening half with Crichton and Burton pulling off separate try-saving efforts to deny Justin Olam and Jahrome Hughes.

Penrith made the most of another error at the start of the second-half by the Storm, extending their lead when a sweeping move to the left allowed Brian To'o to score and put the Panthers 10 points clear.

The Storm battled their way back into the match when a Cameron Munster grubber in the 63rd minute deflected off Viliame Kikau and into the hands of a grateful Ryan Papenhuyzen who converted his own try to set up a grandstand finish.

A Kurt Capewell error followed by a penalty with three minutes to play gave Melbourne one last shot at saving their season.

But the Panthers' resolute defence held firm to send them to a second straight grand final and rematch with their conquerors in the opening week of the finals.

with AAP

Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting