'Lying it’s a** off': NFL under fire over ugly playoff controversy
A major error from an NFL officiating crew has sent America into a frenzy and helped the Cincinnati Bengals clinch their first playoff victory in 30 years.
Late in the first half of the Bengals’ AFC Wild Card playoff clash with the Las Vegas Raiders, there appeared to be an inadvertent whistle blown by a referee as Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow threw a 10-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Tyler Boyd.
'EMBARRASSING': America in disbelief over unthinkable NFL choke
‘HE IS A PROBLEM’: American in frenzy over son of former AFL star
AXED: NFL star cut after walking out on team mid-game
By rule, an inadvertent whistle means the play should have been dead and the touchdown disallowed, however the score was allowed to stand giving the Bengals a 20-3 lead on the stroke of half-time.
The decision proved to be significant in the grand scheme of things, with the Bengals eventually winning the nail-biting contest by a 7-point margin, 26-19.
Oh wow yeah, there definitely was a whistle there. By rule, that TD should have been dead ball.
Refs probably just didn’t want to cost the Bengals a TD because of their own actions. Rough luck for the Raiders.
pic.twitter.com/AIs08180Qo— Brett Kollmann (@BrettKollmann) January 15, 2022
This is every official's nightmare, but while Joe Burrow's pass was in the air, there was an inadvertent whistle. The correct ruling in #LVvsCIN would have been to replay the down. By rule, the play is not reviewable and the TD should have been nullified.https://t.co/AQTYNMaZVr
— Gene Steratore (@GeneSteratore) January 15, 2022
Speaking after the game, NFL senior VP of officiating Walt Anderson said the game’s officiating crew determined the inadvertent whistle occurred after Boyd had caught Burrow’s touchdown pass.
“We confirmed with the referee and the crew that on that play, they got together and talked, they determined that they had a whistle, but that the whistle for them on the field was blown after the receiver caught the ball,” Anderson said.
Anderson was adamant that the officials determined the whistle did not occur while Burrow's pass was in the air.
”That's correct. They did not feel that the whistle was blown before the receiver caught the ball,” Anderson said.
America blows up over NFL refereeing blunder
NFL rules do not allow officials to review when an inadvertent whistle took place, although the play was looked at by video replay officials for other reasons.
“The ruling on the field was a touchdown. But we still have to confirm any reviewable aspect of the play,” Anderson said.
“So, we did confirm that the pass was thrown before the quarterback stepped out of bounds. We also determined that the pass was caught in the end zone by the receiver, who was not out of bounds.”
Not everyone was happy with the explanation from NFL officialdom though, with many taking to social media to criticise the way in which it was handled.
According to NFL SVP of officiating Walt Anderson, the officials on the field determined the inadvertent whistle happened after the receiver caught the ball.
Obviously, that's not true. #Raiders #Bengals— Adam Hill (@AdamHillLVRJ) January 16, 2022
Boy, the NFL is lying its ass off about that "inadvertent whistle."
— Charles P. Pierce (@CharlesPPierce) January 16, 2022
Others felt that the inadvertent whistle had no major impact on the outcome of the play, and allowing the touchdown to stand was the right call.
On that "controversial" play that made it 20-6 Bengals late in 1st half ... the inadvertent whistle came so late in the play, after Burrow released the ball, that I don't believe players hesitated before an open Boyd caught it. The fair & right call was touchdown.
— Skip Bayless (@RealSkipBayless) January 16, 2022
Speaking after the contest, Raiders interim head coach was circumspect when asked about the impact the play had on the outcome of the game
“I think that's a good crew,” Bisaccia said.
“I think there's a lot of things that went on in the game both ways. I got enough problems with my job, I can't do the officiating, too.”
Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.