National player of the year race: The case for/against the top 4 contenders
The national player of the year race is heating up as teams close out the regular season and enter tournament time. Every game and performance has the ability to sway voters. In the last few weeks alone, two top POY contenders went head-to-head, another guided her team to a signature victory and a fourth fell flat for the first time this year.
There is a case to be made for and against each of USC’s JuJu Watkins, UCLA’s Lauren Betts, Notre Dame’s Hannah Hidalgo and UConn’s Paige Bueckers. Bueckers is the only former Naismith and Wooden Award winner playing this season. She became the first freshman to win it in 2021. NCAA all-time scoring champion Caitlin Clark won the 2023 and 2024 Naismith and Wooden Awards. South Carolina’s Aliyah Boston won in 2022.
The four players were named to the Naismith Midseason Team and Wooden Award Late Midseason Top 20 watchlist announced earlier this month. The Naismith Award watchlist will whittle down to 10 semifinalists on March 13 and four finalists on March 24. The winner will be named on April 2 ahead of the Final Four in Tampa. The Wooden Award will be presented on April 11, between the NCAA championship game and WNBA Draft.
Lauren Betts, UCLA
Case for: Betts arguably holds the position of “best and most important player on the best team.” UCLA won 23 games before taking its first loss and spent 12 weeks at No. 1. That success is largely attributable to Betts’ two-way performance.
Since the junior 6-foot-7 center draws double- and triple-teams in the post, her footwork, patience and improved passing ability is crucial. Instead of immediately taking it up herself off the entry pass or on an offensive rebound, she has a better understanding of where the open teammate will be for an uncontested attempt. The team field goal percentage jumped nine percentiles from a season ago and ranks sixth (48.5%).
Just as important is her rim protection and paint patrol. She forces opposing players to alter their shots, and when they dare come at her, she denies them. She secured at least four blocks in eight games and set the program record with nine against Baylor. The Bruins pivot around Betts as their fulcrum on both ends, an impact that can’t be understated in a NPOY race.
Case against: The disadvantage for Betts in the race is a tale as old as the awards themselves. She’s a traditional center without the pizazz and highlight-reel worthy displays of a guard.
The statistics are strong, but few stand out as superior. Brittney Griner won back-to-back NPOY awards at Baylor and A’ja Wilson won in 2018 by ranking top-10 in three categories, including scoring. Iowa big Megan Gustafson led the nation in scoring and efficiency, and was third in rebounding. And though Aliyah Boston wasn’t a heavy scorer when she won in 2022, she ranked fourth in rebounds and led South Carolina to the national title.
UCLA has not played too many contenders this season and when it did, Betts performed short of the NPOY standards set by her peers.
To improve her stock: There will be at least one more chance for Betts to put on a showcase against a fellow national player of the year contender. UCLA hosts Watkins and USC on Saturday. They might also meet again in the Big Ten Tournament. If Betts leads UCLA to a strong NCAA tournament showing, it will work in her favor as it did for Boston.
Regular season schedule: at Wisconsin, vs. USC
Paige Bueckers, UConn
Case for: Few match Bueckers’ efficiency (59.9 effective field goal percentage) and ball control. When on the court, she’s been consistent across the board for UConn and her numbers are in line with her 2021 Naismith and Wooden wins as a freshman. She’s a versatile guard who fills the holes of what the Huskies need.
There’s one key differentiator working in her favor: turnovers. She simply does not turn the ball over. Against Tennessee, which forces an average of 23 per game, Bueckers coughed it up just once. She cut her turnovers in half from the 2.5 she averaged as a freshman, her one red mark over 3½ seasons as a Husky. She ranks sixth in assist/turnover ratio (3.64), a career-best over the 2.43 a season ago.
Case against: Playing in the Big East is a knock on Bueckers’ case when it’s this close. Whereas the other contenders on this list play nine to 11 conference teams ranked within the top 50 in NET, UConn faces just one (Creighton, NET 31). For that type of competition, her contributions could be greater. She doesn’t rank even top-50 in any major category.
And in the big-time non-conference contests, Bueckers hasn’t had the scoring touch from distance or the patented aggressiveness to take over for the Huskies. She missed all four 3s in a loss to Notre Dame, went 2-of-8 against USC and, although she was more efficient in the win over South Carolina, she went 1-of-7 from inside the arc for the second time this season. Those types of performances won’t win an award.
To improve her stock: Because Bueckers set the bar high as a freshman, she has to considerably level up annually. That’s tough with improving parity and increasingly stellar player performances. The redshirt senior needs powerful offensive showcases in the Big East tournament and beyond to make it a closer contest with the other three on this list.
Regular season schedule: vs. Creighton, vs. Marquette
Hannah Hidalgo, Notre Dame
Case for: In the simplest terms, Hidalgo is a walking bucket and defensive menace. Her ability to consistently pack the stat line is uncanny. She’s a few assists and steals shy of repeating an average of 20 points, five rebounds, four assists and four steals in a season. Last year, she became the first to do that since at least 2009-10, the extent of the Her Hoop Stats database.
The 5-6 sophomore is an energetic, dynamic guard whose crisp shooting places her tops in scoring. She’s a strong ball-handler with a quick step to blow by defenders and the vision to find teammates if there’s a better opportunity.
It’s also what makes her a roving defensive problem. She lights up the scoreboard while also guarding the opposing teams' best player and usually picking their pocket a few times. The strongest piece of Hidalgo’s case is her performance against the nation’s best teams and players. Her numbers actually go up when playing ranked opponents or on major networks. In wins over USC and UConn, she averaged 26.5 points (44.7 FG%), eight rebounds, eight assists and four steals.
Case against: Those performances were from the first two months of the season. Notre Dame hadn’t played top competition lately until Sunday’s loss to N.C. State. It was one of Hidalgo’s subpar showings in a battle of prolific backcourts. It will cast doubt on the strongest piece of her case when she did not score in either overtime period (on merely three attempts) and fouled out.
There’s a claim that no one has more assistance offensively than Hidalgo, who has meshed in seamlessly with point guard Olivia Miles after her return from an ACL injury. The duo are each former All-Americans and viable candidates to make the list together this time.
To improve her stock: Notre Dame finishes its regular season with the ACC’s top teams, allowing Hidalgo to bounce back onto her trend of playing her best against the best. She will be tasked with showing the NC State game was an anomaly.
Regular season schedule: vs. Florida State, vs. Louisville
JuJu Watkins, USC
Case for: Watkins’ bag is deep and she can take over games in an instant with her size, strength and explosiveness. Look no further than a do-it-all showcase to upset former No. 1 UCLA that propelled her back toward the top of the NPOY conversation.
The 6-2 sophomore guard scored 38 of USC’s 71 points (including all of the second and third-quarter scoring), but it was her defensive effort that was more impressive as she finished with eight blocks. She ranks first among guards in blocks (96th percentile overall) and is one of three to average more than 1.6 per game. That effort has made USC a top-five defense.
Watkins started the season more efficiently from the field than as a freshman, boosting her 3-point average and cutting turnovers down by 25%. The Trojans rely heavily on her to create and she delivers, particularly off the dribble in isolation.
Case against: Watkins’ big-time showing against UCLA was crucial to getting into the race because she fell into a bit of a sophomore slump before it. Efficiency is still lacking in Watkins' game; while she continues to be a top-five Division I scorer, her field goal percentage languishes in the 60th percentile range. Improving her off-ball movement and shooting, as well as focusing on smarter shot selection, will boost those marks.
To improve her stock: Recency bias is real and Watkins has the best shot of any at staying top of mind. The Trojans finish the season at UCLA, where a clutch two-way performance by Watkins could lock up the trophy. Re-igniting her touch from 3-point range throughout the tournament would give her a boost as well.
Regular season schedule: at UCLA
