Josh Aloiai cops fresh fallout at Manly as NRL fans slam 'pathetic' Warriors call
The Warriors snatched a draw against Manly as a result of the contentious incident.
The NRL has dealt Josh Aloiai and Manly a fresh blow after charging the prop for dangerous contact, following a controversial incident late in Saturday's 22-22 draw with the Warriors. Aloiai tried put pressure on Warriors half Shaun Johnson as he attempted to kick a two-point field goal to send the game into extra time but made contact with Johnson's legs and gave away a match-levelling penalty from right in front.
The call sparked debate around the game, with many fans arguing it was Johnson's leg that made contact with Aloiai's arm, and not the other way around. But on Sunday, the Manly prop was hit a grade-two dangerous contact charge that will see him banned for one match. That means Aloiai will miss Manly's trip to Gold Coast next weekend with an early guilty plea, or risk a second game on the sidelines if he fights the charge and loses.
The development comes after Manly coach Anthony Seibold gave a measured response to the controversy that allowed the Warriors to snatch a nail-biting draw with the Sea Eagles in Auckland. Manly led by 22-14 with 55 seconds left in regulation time, but a late try to Dallin Waetene-Zelezniak and a penalty goal to Johnson from the contentious Aloiai incident tied the game up.
With three seconds left on the clock, Johnson attempted a two-point field goal from more than 40 metres out to send the match to golden point. However, his kicking foot came into contact with Aloiai as the Manly prop tried to put pressure on Johnson, constituting a penalty. That gave Johnson an easy shot from in front of the posts to send the game to extra time, with neither side able to find a winning score of any sort and the match ending in a draw.
The Warriors' controversial late penalty proved the game's biggest talking point, with many viewers arguing that Aloiai never initiated the contact with Johnson, whose leg followed through and hit his arms as a result of the field goal attempt. Seibold was not prepared to be drawn on the controversy after the match and gave a classy response to the incident in his post-match press conference.
"It's probably something I don't want to make comment on," Seibold said afterwards. "Because if I say it shouldn't have been a penalty I'll be called a whinger. If I say it should have been a penalty then potentially I'm not looking after the players in my group. It was adjudicated a penalty and we get on with it."
NRL world divided over contentious Warriors penalty
Manly skipper Daly Cherry-Evans said he understood the decision to protect the kicker, much like the rules in professional football that many fans argue should not be applied in rugby league. But Warriors coach Andrew Webster was adamant that it was a clear penalty. "It's definitely the right call," Webster said. "It's unfortunate. I don't think Josh meant it. He's trying to charge the ball down.
"He's going for a field goal and Josh has to do that. He's got to go for the ball. It's unfortunate what happened, but it's fortunate for us." Many other angry viewers took to social media in disagreement though, calling it a "pathetic" and "dubious" call that denied Manly what would have been a brave victory against a fast-finishing Warriors.
Pathetic call to award a penalty on full time to the Warriors. Since when can’t you pressure a kicker?
— Steven (@StratosH9) April 13, 2024
Aloiai didn’t make contact with the leg - leg made contact with Aloiai. Difference.
— Latemail Man (@LateMailMan) April 13, 2024
With all due respect. There was no dive at the leg of SJ. It was the kicker basically kicking Aloiai in his follow thru... then the kicker pretending to have a leg break. That's so weak.
— Cam Sánchez (@CamMagicMan) April 13, 2024
No mention of the pathetic penalty given to the Warriors to lock it up? What a joke your organization has become.
— XxXJuzXxX (@BMJuzz07) April 13, 2024
Warriors made a great comeback and were never out of it. Manly didnt deserve to lose o that penalty. Besides that penalty it was a nailbiter
— brett chong (@imchookiestoo) April 13, 2024
Not allowed to do it. Penalty every day. Hopefully the NRL are consistent and he gets four weeks like the warriors player did last week
— Matthew Boyce (@hornbybrown) April 13, 2024
As a warriors fan we deserved to lose, we were awful and never a penalty
— Harry (@BeyanHarrison) April 13, 2024
That bullshit penalty cost Manly the game and saved a draw for the Warriors.
Aloiai didn't attack Johnson's leg. Liam Kennedy should hand in his referees ticket for that one.— .H.Ɔ.ꟼ (@IWasBornIn1975) April 13, 2024
Fast-finishing Warriors snatch draw with spirited Manly
Manly were on track to spring an upset against the high-flying Warriors after blowing the home side away to race out to a 16-0 lead in the first half. A Cherry-Evans double and a third Manly try for Tommy Talau put the visitors in command before the home side scored two tries in four minutes, including an intercept to Waetene-Zelezniak on halftime that made it 16-10 at the break.
The Warriors dominated second-half field position as their middles ran amok and fullback Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad ran for a mind-boggling 337 metres at the back. Cherry-Evans put Manly on the front foot again though, sending Ben Trbojevic over for a try to make it 22-12 early in the second half, before the youngest of the Trbojevic brothers hobbled off with a hamstring injury late on.
Manly also lost Toff Sipley (knee), while Warriors prop Jazz Tevaga (hamstring) finished a brutal contest on crutches. But a piece of Johnson magic got the Warriors back in the match when he stepped Tom Trbojevic from 40 metres out to score and make it 22-14. The veteran halfback then stood in a tackle and threw the last pass for Waetene-Zelezniak's late try to set up the grandstand finish.
Webster's men fluffed two chances to win it in golden point with the better field position, the first came when Tohu Harris dropped a ball on the attack, before a 30-metre field-goal shot from Johnson went well wide in the second half of extra time. In contrast, Manly struggled to get out of their own end and were limited to two long-range field goal efforts from Cherry-Evans that fell short.
with AAP