Horror extent of Christian Petracca's injuries revealed as Demons ripped over 'deplorable' move
The Melbourne Demons' call to let their star player return to the field has been heavily scrutinised.
AFL fans are questioning Melbourne's decision to send Christian Petracca back onto the field against Collingwood, with the Demons star revealed to have suffered four broken ribs, lacerations to the spleen and a small puncture in his lung on Tuesday morning. Petracca copped a knee to the ribs from Darcy Moore in the first quarter of the King's Birthday clash on Monday and looked to be in agony.
He came off the field for treatment at the end of the first quarter, but went back on in the second term in a move that left many shocked. The Demons superstar was largely a passenger and looked like he didn't want to kick the ball, before he was put out of his misery and subbed out of the game at half-time.
The 28-year-old was transferred to hospital by ambulance during the game. On Tuesday morning it was revealed Petracca sustained four broken ribs, a lacerated spleen and a punctured lung, and underwent surgery on his spleen on Monday night.
"Obviously, Christian's health is the No.1 priority for us at the moment," Melbourne football boss Alan Richardson said in a statement. "The next few weeks will be crucial, and we'll be monitoring his progress closely to make sure he heals properly and fully.
"As his recovery progresses, we will look towards a return to play timeline. He's obviously an extremely important player for the team, but his health and recovery are our top priorities right now."
Should Christian Petracca have been subbed out earlier?
The brutal extent of his injuries only adds to furore that erupted over the Demons' decision to allow Petracca to return to the field. Demons coach Simon Goodwin explained it was 'standard procedure' with broken ribs to get some pain-killers and try to keep playing. Petracca wanted to test the injury out in the second quarter and see if he could keep playing, but only managed five disposals in the time he was back on the field.
Petracca preparing to come back on. Remarkable. #AFLPiesDees pic.twitter.com/uju0TkWPEg
— Paddy Grindlay (@pad_nauseum) June 10, 2024
Fans on social media were highly critical of the decision to send Petracca back out considering he risked an even more serious injury if he copped a heavy hit. Some suggested the decision should have been taken out of the player's hands if he wanted to keep going, with others noted that the Magpies kicked away to a big lead while Petracca was offering very little.
"If it was player’s decision then they should have not allowed it. He could have sustained lacerated kidney, lacerated spleen, or ribs, who knows? Hope he’ll be okay," one person wrote. Another commented: "Putting Petracca back on the field when he’s now off to hospital was a deplorable decision. This club is rotting."
Speaking in commentary for Fox Footy, David King said: “You can’t help but feel this is their season walking off the ground here. He’s the reason they score, he’s the reason their forward 50 corrects. The domino effect - the player that replaces him in the midfield or up forward is nowhere near that level. It’s pretty much Max Gawn or bust.”
Incredible decision by the coach and doctors to send him back out
Putting players health first not a thing at Melbourne?— Sam (@sammytee90) June 10, 2024
If it was player’s decision then they should have not allowed it. He could have sustained lacerated kidney, lac spleen, or # ribs who knows?
Hope he’ll be okay.— Catherine Pearce (@Catheri68047718) June 10, 2024
Putting Petracca back on the field when he’s now off to hospital was a deplorable decision.
This club is rotting— Hayley (@Hayleyyemma) June 10, 2024
I can't believe he was allowed to play for another quarter. I don't doubt the medical staff do their best, but are the procedures up to scratch if they result in this?
Best wishes to Trac for a speedy recovery.— Brett (@furphy99) June 10, 2024
I’m with King tonight over Jason. Why on earth was Petracca sent back on the field and not straight to hospital. You don’t listen to players you take precautions.
He’s now in hospital over night wrong scans afteer the event— Andrew McCallum (@Andrew_McCallum) June 10, 2024
Melbourne are literally playing with 17 on the field with Petracca on the field. As soon as he came back on Pies slammed on 3 goals. Petracca needs to think long term and big picture make the sub Dees this doesn't serve Petracca or Melb a purpose. #AFLPiesDees
— Rick1807 (@rick_costa18) June 10, 2024
Disgraceful to see an injured player back on the field. Petracca may have rib fractures, or a punctured spleen from rib fractures. I used to get tired of these guys being brought into my ED because they'd continued to play instead of rest. IMHO a breach of #WHS #AFLPiesDees
— Susan Lily (@SusanLilyOz) June 10, 2024
RELATED:
Former teammates rejected as Dustin Martin holds firm before 300th
Simon Goodwin goes public with 'terrible' new revelation about family
Simon Goodwin remains optimistic despite Demons' rut
The Demons have now lost four of their last five games - including an embarrassing 92-point loss to Fremantle last weekend - and have slipped to 10th on the ladder with a 7-6 record. But Goodwin played down concerns.
"We're optimistic that we're just going through a little patch at the moment that we need to work through and we'll come out the other side," the coach said. "But most teams will go through a little patch like we're going through.
"But we're very optimistic about what's possible as we move forward through this. There's some emergence of some young forwards working together more consistently that we'll look to continue on with and our method will continually get better."
Melbourne will give their players a break before returning from a bye next week to play North Melbourne. "It's a chance to do some training and get ourselves fresh and get ourselves really in a really good space," Goodwin said.
"This game, it's small margins in a lot of ways. It's never as bad and never as good (as it looks). And today we walk away losing a game of footy, but we walk away optimistic about our path forward. We don't sit here comfortable with where our game sits but we've got work to do and we get a chance to do it over the bye."
with AAP