The devastating moment EPL referee made controversial decision
Premier League referee Lee Probert’s decision to book Demarai Gray for taking his shirt off in celebrating his winner for Leicester City against Cardiff City has provoked a storm of criticism.
But Leicester manager Claude Puel has defied the controversy to accept the yellow card handed to his goal-scoring player.
The occasion was charged with emotion following the death of Leicester owner Vichai Srivaddhanaprabha in a helicopter crash immediately after the club’s match last Saturday.
Before kickoff a wreath was laid and Leicester’s team linked arms for an immaculately observed a minute’s silence when a huge tribute banner was unfurled among the 3,000 visiting supporters.
The game turned on Gray’s 55th-minute goal, which sparked wild scenes.
The 22-year-old immediately whipped off his top to reveal an undershirt saying “For Khun Vichai” in memory of the Thai billionaire.
Gray’s teammates joined him in front of the away contingent, many of whom also sported t-shirts honouring their former owner.
But the mood changed when referee Probert followed the letter of the law and booked Gray under a mandatory FIFA rule that says players must not remove their shirt over their head.
Footage of Gray’s celebration showed Probert’s concern in the background, an uneasy smile hinting he was aware of what was to come.
The decision was roundly criticised by football fans – with a relatively low portion of viewers defending the whistleblower.
Leicester’s Puel, who had told all of his players they did not have to play if they were not emotionally ready, was one who understood the decision.
“We played like professionals and it was important for the referee to be professional too,” he said.
Former referee Peter Walton told BT Sport he had “every sympathy” with Probert.
“Sometimes referees have to do what they have to do and in this instance the law is quite clear on it,” he said.
“If a player removes his shirt for religious slogans or anything of that nature then he’s cautioned. I could see Lee Probert thinking ‘oh no, why has he done that?’ He’s going to be the villain of the piece in a game where everybody’s eyes are focused on something else.”
Asked if he could have just turned around and pretended not to have seen it, Walton said: “Yes, but then he’d have to explain his actions on Monday morning and he probably didn’t want to do that.”
Amid Football journalist and presenter Jacqui Oatley said it was a “no-win situation”
Harsh for people to hammer Lee Probert for booking Gray who ripped off shirt celebrating goal, with message “For Vichai”. Refs can’t decide on the spot which t-shirt messages are more poignant than others. Ref would’ve hated booking him but felt he had to. No win situation.
— Jacqui Oatley (@JacquiOatley) November 3, 2018
Would Lee Probert’s bosses really have told him off for not booking Gray though? And if they did then there are serious problems… Players aren’t robots, referees shouldn’t be either. Sympathise with Probert in a way but these are special circumstances.
— John Bennett (@JohnBennettBBC) November 3, 2018
Lee Probert just doing his job. The images show he looks uncomfortable booking Demarai Gray but he’s got little choice unless given permission by the FA not to. Don’t hammer the bloke.
— Andrew Musgrove (@ADMusgrove) November 3, 2018
Demarai Gray scores an excellent goal, half-volley to Ben Chilwell's cross. Removes shirt to reveal: For Khun Vichai. Immediately Lee Probert bows his head, clearly in expectation of this event. He shows Gray the yellow card once the celebrations are over
— Laurie Whitwell (@lauriewhitwell) November 3, 2018
What a shame that Lee Probert showed a yellow to Gray after the goal. Surely discretion should have been applied, despite the rule. Hopefully it will be rescinded. #LeicesterCity
— Paul Fabretti (@paulfabretti) November 3, 2018
I know it’s the rules but @FA needs to rethink ref #LeeProbert booking @LCFC Demarai Gray for pulling off his shirt to reveal T-shirt with ‘For Khun Vichai’ after scoring pic.twitter.com/yesQxrY3Q0
— Richard Frediani (@FredianiITV) November 3, 2018
I hate that ‘excessive celebration’ rule anyway, but today should be a day it isn’t enforced. Would love to have known if Lee Probert would have booked every Leicester City player if they had all taken their shirts off to reveal tributes when Gray scored. #lcfc
— Oliver Harbord (@ojharbord) November 3, 2018
with Reuters