'Worst decision ever': Cricket world fumes over 'absolute disgrace'

Andrew Reid
·5-min read
Pictured here, Andrew Tye is shocked by the not out call against Usman Khawaja.
Usman Khawaja was somehow given not out in one of the most baffling decisions in a long time. Pic: Fox Sports

In what is being labelled one of the worst umpiring decisions in Big Bash history, a controversial incident on Tuesday night has reignited calls for a decision review system (DRS) to be brought in for the Australian domestic Twenty20 tournament.

Sydney Thunder batsman Usman Khawaja somehow survived what most viewers, commentators and players thought was an obvious nick during his side's seven-wicket win over the Perth Scorchers.

'NOT GREAT': Steve Smith's worrying injury admission

BONE OF CONTENTION: Test great wants little-used rule implemented

ROUGH: Brutal Virat Kohli reality exposed after first Test shocker

Replays showed Khawaja had clearly edged the ball while trying to drive Scorchers bowler Andrew Tye, with the batsman standing his ground as he waited for the umpire's verdict.

What happened next left just about everyone watching completely gobsmacked.

Umpire Simon Lightbody could be heard telling Tye he believed Khawaja's bat had hit the ground, despite the bat being nowhere near the turf.

Khawaja was on 18 at the time, and made just three more before falling to Aaron Hardie.

Some viewers pointed the finger at the batsman, insisting he should have walked when he knew he nicked the ball, although Khawaja had every right to stand his ground.

Nevertheless, the incident sparked widespread outrage on social media, with many fans calling for the umpire to be stood down over one of the most extraordinary howlers seen in a long time.

Controversy reignites calls for DRS

The incident reignited calls for the DRS, with Khawaja on the wrong end of another poor call nine days ago in the Thunder's loss to Melbourne Stars.

Mitch Marsh - himself the victim of an lbw howler in the Scorchers' washed-out clash with the Melbourne Stars last week - became the latest star to call for change.

"As a player you like to see stuff introduced, I would be all for it," Marsh, who expects to be back bowling for the Scorchers on Monday against Adelaide, said.

"It's probably above my pay grade to really be commenting on that. But I'd certainly be all for it if it was introduced."

Money is believed to be the biggest hurdle for Cricket Australia, as AAP understands it would cost around $2 million to have DRS in place at all games.

Seen here, Perth Scorchers allrounder Mitch Marsh gets ready to bowl.
Mitch Marsh has joined the chorus of voices calling for DRS in the Big Bash. Pic: Getty

While broadcasters do show ball-tracking technology, there are suggestions that would need to be improved while snicko and hot spot are also currently absent.

However the likes of former Australia captain Adam Gilchrist and Thunder skipper Callum Ferguson have argued a system where only replays were used would still be better than the current situation, without increasing costs.

The BBL's maiden season in 2011-12 allowed third umpires to overrule incorrect decisions off replays, without using added technology.

Australia batsman Glenn Maxwell tweeted on Tuesday night seemingly backing a return to that style of system if need be.

"We get that umpiring isn't easy!!" he posted.

"But surely with a stump mic, a bunch of different camera angles, and a basic understanding of cricket, the right decision could've been made without any of the fancy DRS bells and whistles?

"It was introduced to eliminate the howler."

But Marsh believes it has to be a case of 'all or nothing'.

"If you had just on-TV replays you would get rid of the absolute howlers but leave yourself open if there was really close calls," Marsh said.

"It's probably a case of (needing) to go all in, or not (at all)."

with AAP

Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.