'Beyond ridiculous': Raiders fans seething over refereeing debacle

Cronulla have left Canberra’s finals hopes hanging by a thread and boosted their own top-four chances with a controversial 28-24 NRL defeat of the Raiders.

After the Sharks led 22-6 at the break on Friday night, Canberra centre Joey Leilua crossed twice to narrow the gap to four early in the second half before Cronulla were awarded a contentious try in the 57th minute.

As Cronulla spread the ball right, the ball brushed past the upper arm of centre Jesse Ramien, which appeared to prompt touch judge Rick MacFarlane to put up his flag despite no one crossing the sideline.

PLEASE EXPLAIN: Bulldogs in hot water over dressing room incident

The touch judge raises his flag for a knock on. Pic: Fox Sports

Referee Gerard Sutton then put the whistle to his mouth – at which point the Raiders’ defence stopped – but didn’t blow it, allowing Sione Katoa to cross and make it 28-18.

The play was sent to the bunker as a no-try for a possible Ramien knock-on, but none was found and the on-field call was overturned.


Stand-in Raiders skipper Josh Hodgson politely criticised a number of referee calls after the game, calling it “frustrating”.

Braith Anasta took it one step further, calling the referee’s effort “diabolical”.

Meanwhile, coach Ricky Stuart had a measured response in the post-match press conference.

“I just criticised my players in there for not playing the whistle. Then they tell me the flag went up and the referee called knock on,” Stuart said.

“So what are they meant to do?”

Hodgson said it was a natural reaction for the players to stop in the line.

“You saw the touchie’s flag. He put it up and half put it down … as soon as you see a flag you stop on your feet,” Hodgson said.

“We were all just waiting for the whistle and they ran through and scored.

“He called no try, and I don’t think there was definitive proof he didn’t touch it.”

The touch judge’s flag goes up. Pic: Fox Sports

The NRL admitted after the game the touch judge had erred and the bunker’s decision would also be the subject of an investigation.

“It wasn’t out. The touchie shouldn’t have put his flag up,” an NRL spokesman said.

“The subjective part about bunker decisions around the review (of the try) is going to be reviewed.”

“One of the worst refereeing performances I’ve seen in the history of the game,” Anasta said on Fox Sports.

Unsurprisingly Raiders fans were blowing up.








Radio presenter, Mark Levy, took to Twitter to reveal the touch judge at the centre of the incident, Tony McFarlane, would be thrown under the bus for his mistake.



Raiders fullback Brad Abbey was then denied a try with 10 minutes to go as Canberra looked to mount a comeback despite the ball appearing to have been thrown backwards.

Jordan Rapana then crossed with three minutes to play, but the Sharks held on to win after having 60 per cent of the ball.

Referee Gerard Sutton is faced by confused Raiders players. Pic: Getty

The result moves the Sharks to 26 competition points after they entered the round in sixth spot, and in a position to push for a top-four finish with the softest run home of the teams around them.

Canberra can now likely afford only one more loss this year after entering the weekend four points behind Brisbane, with five games still to play against top-eight teams.

Valentine Holmes and Wade Graham were earlier superb for the Sharks as they enjoyed 67 per cent of possession in the first half, although the latter injured his groin at halftime and did not return.

Ricky Stuart struggled to contain his emotion in the post-match presser. Pic: Getty

The pair scored crucial tries just before the break after Cronulla looked as if they were going to carry only a six-point advantage into halftime.

This was despite the Sharks having all the ball and at one stage playing against a 12-man team, with Rapana sin-binned.

Holmes also finished the night with three linebreaks and one try-saving tackle on Josh Hodgson, and Andrew Fifita and Ramien crossed in the first half.

With AAP