'Beyond cruel': Olympic pentathlon marred by horse controversy

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
·Sports Reporter
·6-min read
In this article:
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
Germany's Annika Schleu cries as her horse doesn't co-operate during the Tokyo Olympics modern pentathlon.
German pentathlon competitor Annika Schleu was left in tears after her horse flatly refused to tackle any of the obstacles in the show jumping portion of the competition. Pictures: Getty Images

The modern pentathlon is one of the most unique events on the Olympic schedule, but the event in Tokyo has been criticised for its 'random' nature after a leading competitor was dumped through no fault of her own.

Consisting of five disciplines, fencing, swimming, running, shooting and horse riding, competitors must display an uncommon level of versatility to succeed.

'NOT OK YET': Aussie Olympian's brutal interview after injury

'DEEPLY DISAPPOINTING': Aussies in hot water over Olympic Covid breach

However the show jumping portion of the pentathlon at the Tokyo Olympics has fallen into controversy due to a unique rule in the event.

Athletes are not permitted to use a horse of the own for the show jumping section - instead, they are given a horse selected at random and have 20 minutes to bond with the animal before being sent out on course.

However on Friday night, several of the horses given to riders just weren't up for the task, with multiple riders falling out of contention due to unwilling steeds.

None fell further than Germany's Annika Schleu, who held the lead heading into the horse riding event but fell completely out of contention when her mount absolutely refused to cooperate.

Schleu, who finished fourth in the event at the 2016 Rio Olympics, was in tears riding around the course as her horse flatly refused to tackle any of the obstacles on course.

Several other riders also had difficulties with their mounts, with commentator and former British pentathlete Heather Fell describing Schleu's predicament as a 'real life nightmare'.

“This is hard to watch, hard to commentate on,” Fell continued.

Natalya Coyle of Ireland also suffered from an unhelpful steed, plummeting from fourth in the rankings to 19th.

“I suppose it’s just added disappointment because to be third in events and to be so close and to feel like it’s a bit snatched away from you, it’s really disappointing," Coyle said.

“That’s pentathlon, unfortunately. I knew it was going to be tough when I watched the first rider not get around so I knew that was really tough.

“I thought I had made a good plan and it worked a lot in the arena but he just didn’t want to go near it.

Fans question 'stupid' modern pentathlon rule

The devastating turn of events lefts some fans querying why athletes were not permitted to use their own mounts for the show jumping section.

Many felt there was an element of chance involved when it came to the show jumping, with the recalcitrant horses not giving several riders an opportunity to prove their riding skills.

"Natalya Coyle draws a horse who just doesn’t fancy it today. And that is the horrendous luck of this draw. Crazy event. She went into showjumping in 4th & leaves it in 19th. Beyond cruel," Irish reporter Jacqui Hurley wrote.

"Serious questions need to be asked in the aftermath about the standard of horses. Huge disparity between many of them was clearly visible."

Others on Twitter were similarly perplexed by what had unfolded.

Kate French snapped Great Britain's 21-year gold medal drought in the women's modern pentathlon, also breaking Australian Chloe Esposito's Olympic record from Rio.

With the Australian defending Olympic champion missing the Tokyo Games after recently becoming a mum, French stormed home in the final event, the laser run, to take top spot.

Australia's representative Marina Carrier, in her first Olympics, finished 27th after falling down the standings in the final round.

Lithuanian world record holder Laura Asadauskaite won silver and Hungary's Sarolta Kovacs was third.

Starting 15 seconds back French won the 3200 metres laser run - which sees competitors running 800m laps before picking up their laser gun to take five shots at a target - to secure the title.

French's accuracy gave her an edge on her rivals, missing just two of her 22 shots.

She also performed strongly through the first three events, sitting sixth after the fencing, which was held on Thursday, and then coming eighth in the 200m freestyle swim.

For the first time at the Olympics, all the disciplines were held in one stadium, with a pool erected at one end of Tokyo Stadium.

French picked up one extra point in the fencing bonus round and was then one of very few riders to go clear in the show jumping, although she did pick up six time penalties.

She finished with a tally of 1385 points to eclipse Esposito's Olympic record of 1372.

With AAP

Watch 'Mind Games', the new series from Yahoo Sport Australia exploring the often brutal mental toil elite athletes go through in pursuit of greatness:

Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting