Aston Villa 4-2 Celtic - the fans' verdict

We asked for your thoughts after Wednesday's Champions League game between Aston Villa and Celtic.

Here are some of your comments:

Duncan: Great result, although nerve-racking at times. We were stunning going forward but there was awful defending at times. Credit to Celtic, who looked very competitive. We are in dreamland to qualify in the top eight, which I did not expect. The lack of play-off games will be a help in the sense of giving the players a rest.

Rob: A dogged performance from the lads. Despite some poor finishing at times, we were ruthless in our play. I'm really pleased for Morgan Rogers, he should have took the penalty and he was my man of the match.

Stephen: What Unai Emery is achieving with this squad of players is nothing short of remarkable. Rogers has announced himself as a top-class player.

Adrian: Celtic gave Villa some nervy moments but Rogers, Watkins and Ramsey were magnificent. I'm looking forward to the draw.

Matthew: Great win for Villa. The team looked a lot more balanced and were creating a lot of chances. We are still missing a bit of quality in key positions but hopefully, with a couple of new players and injured players coming back, things should look better. Well done lads!