Ben Stokes was involved in controversial scenes on the final day of the fifth Ashes Test after he opted to use a review on a catch that he appeared to clearly know he hadn't taken legally. Stokes jumped up to take a one-handed catch after the ball ricocheted off Steve Smith's glove to leg-slip just before lunch.
The England captain took the ball cleanly but accidentally let go of it as he was about to throw it up in celebration. It brought back memories of Herschelle Gibbs' infamous dropped catch at the 1999 World Cup when Steve Waugh allegedly told him "you just dropped the World Cup".
'NO WAY IN THE WORLD': Ricky Ponting calls for investigation over ball
'WHAT DID YOU SAY': Aussies players in nasty confrontation with fan
Stokes immediately knew he hadn't completed the catch under ICC laws, which state players must be in full control of their body even while celebrating a catch. But the England captain opted to use a review anyway after appearing to be talked into it by his teammates.
The England players didn't appear to realise that Stokes had fumbled the ball and advised him to use the review thinking he'd completed the catch. Under Law 33.3 of the official rule book: “The act of making a catch shall start from the time when the ball first comes into contact with a fielder’s person and shall end when a fielder obtains complete control over both the ball and his/her own movement."
It was an easy decision for the third umpire because Stokes was never in control during his celebratory throw, but the England captain appeared to convince himself that he had completed the catch. Stokes was involved in a heated argument with the umpires as the players left the field for lunch, although some suggested he was unhappy that he'd lost a review in the process of checking the catch, rather than disagreeing with the actual decision.
Cricket world turns on Ben Stokes over 'shameful' scenes
The 'spirit of cricket' has been a big talking point throughout the Ashes series, with England left fuming over Jonny Bairstow's dismissal in the second Test when he was stumped by Alex Carey after unwittingly walking out of his crease. So it was only fair that cricket fans turned the tables on Stokes on Sunday for reviewing a catch he clearly knew he hadn't completed, before arguing with the umpires to boot.
Former Aussie Test bowler Chadd Sayers tweeted: “How funny. Spirit of cricket when it’s on their terms.
“Knew he dropped it and still went up for review …. Now arguing with (the umpires) walking off. Can’t have it both ways Stokesy!”
Sports journalist Ronny Lerner commented: “Never looked like he controlled it in real time. He would’ve known it, and yet he still reviewed. The captain of the country no less Piers Morgan!! Why I never!! What a scandal! Spirit of cricket has officially died old boy.”
Others described Stokes' actions as 'embarrassing' and 'pathetic'.
Absolutely not out and to be honest was pretty shocking that Stokes reviewed it. You can see he was pressured into the review by others, but you can see from his initial reaction that he knew he’d dropped it.
After all the talk of “the spirit of cricket” this was embarrassing.
— Mathew Tooke (@smok1279) July 31, 2023
Oh dear... Ben Stokes, the English captain of all people, tries to claim a catch that he clearly fumbles and does not control.
That is simply not in the Spirit of Cricket. What an absolute disgrace he is and a hypocrite to boot. Shameful.#Ashes23
— ChadPhillips (@TheChadPhillips) July 31, 2023
Stokes perfectly knew he had Gibbs'd it and yet reviewed? Shameful. https://t.co/M1xn3lI6P6
— Prasanna M R (@mrprasanna23) July 31, 2023
Can’t piss and moan about “spirit of cricket” and morality and then go and do that.
The fact Stokes said he wouldn’t want to win a game like that (Bairstow stumping) but then he’d be happy to win with a dropped catch is hypocrisy at its finest.
— Trav (@TravisMaher22) July 31, 2023
— Marshall Pascoe (@MarshallJPascoe) July 31, 2023
Stokes' mishap didn't end up costing England, who went on to win by 49 runs. Australia suffered collapses of 4-11 and 7-70 to be all out for 334 in their attempt to chase down an Oval record of 384. The win for England sealed a 2-2 series draw and denied Australia their first outright series victory on English soil since 2001.
Sign up to our newsletter and score the biggest sport stories of the week.