Advertisement

'Amazingly bad': Umpires panned after controversial AFL game-winner

A 50-50 split image shows a Fremantle fan yelling and gesturing on the left, and Carlton players celebrating on the right.
Fremantle Dockers fans were furious after a series of umpiring decisions led to Carlton's Jack Newnes booting a match-winning goal after the siren on Saturday night. Pictures: Getty Images

Fremantle coach Justin Longmuir reckons Carlton players pulled the wool over the umpire's eyes during the controversial finish to Saturday night's match - but he doesn't feel hard done by.

The Dockers suffered a heart-breaking four-point loss when Blues midfielder Jack Newnes nailed a 45m set shot from the boundary line after the final siren, lifting Carlton to the 5.10 (40) to 5.6 (36) victory at Optus Stadium.

'GREAT SADNESS': Ablett family rocked by 'huge tragedy'

'GOT A CONTRACT': Victoria bullish about AFL grand final moving

A series of controversial decisions led to the match-winning goal - and Fremantle were on the wrong side of all of them.

Arguably the biggest talking point was the fact that it should have been Michael Gibbons - not Newnes - who was awarded the final shot on goal.

With just 16 seconds remaining, Dockers forward Matt Taberner was pinned for deliberate out-of-bounds - a decision that looked correct.

Sam Docherty quickly played on but his kick inside 50m sailed out on the full.

However, the Blues were awarded a down-the-field free-kick given that Docherty was bowled over by Andrew Brayshaw during a failed smother attempt from the Fremantle midfielder - a decision that immediately sparked debate.

Gibbons was clearly the closest player to the ball when it sailed out on the field.

But the umpires were somehow convinced that it was Newnes who had been closest.

Longmuir was well aware of the mistake, but he copped the decision on the chin.

"Every team would have tried to do the same thing, and they probably pulled one over the umpire's eyes," Longmuir said.

"But that's alright. That's footy. We'll take it, cop it on the chin, move on and get better.

"I think they did a pretty good job of getting the right player the ball. But I would have been asking our players to do exactly the same thing in the same situation. So the result is done, it's in the book."

Plenty of fans were in awe of Newnes’ shot to win the game, but many were also perplexed by the circumstances that led to it.

On social media, fans pointed out the kick shouldn’t have been taken downfield, heavily criticising the whistleblowers for the chaotic end to the game.

Carlton thrilled to escape with AFL win

Carlton coach David Teague was happy the ball was in Newnes' hands.

"He's a really straight kick, which I like. Especially when it's a bit wet and slippery, you don't really want to be kicking around corners," Teague said.

"I just sat there and enjoyed it. That kick changes four points for our football club."

But he also said Gibbons would have been a good option.

The Blues are pictured piling on Jack Newnes after he kicked a match-winning goal after the siren.
The Blues celebrate after Jack Newnes scores a goal after the siren to beat the Dockers on Saturday night. (Photo by Will Russell/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

"He likes having those shots at training and kicks them quite regularly, so I would have been quite comfortable if he had that kick as well," Teague said.

Longmuir didn't feel Brayshaw did anything wrong in his smothering attempt on Docherty that led to the relayed free-kick.

"From what I saw, Andy Brayshaw goes to smother and makes contact," Longmuir said.

"If the same situation arose again, I'd ask Andy Brayshaw to put frontal pressure on and try to smother the ball. That's where I sit with it."