Tom Papley at centre of 'comical' call as Collingwood rage: 'What a joke'
Magpies fans have been left ruing a dubious umpire decision involving Tom Papley that could have cost them a spot in the AFL grand final after a devastating one-point loss to the Sydney Swans at the SCG.
Sydney repeated history, winning through to the AFL grand final with an epic one-point preliminary final win over Collingwood at the SCG.
'DEVASTATED': Lions veteran takes swipe at coach in 'sad' farewell act
OUCH: James Hird's coaching hopes tarnished by Zach Merrett comments
In front of a heaving capacity crowd of 45,608, the Swans rushed through a Collingwood behind in the last few seconds to secure the 14.11 (95) to 14.10 (94) win.
They will play Geelong in a grand final for the first time next Saturday at the MCG.
However, Collingwood fans were left fuming when Papley was paid a mark and kicked his third goal for Sydney midway through the last term when he could have been penalised for a push on Darcy Moore.
The score stood at 88-74 when Papley and Moore contested the ball.
Papley could have been penalised for a push in the back, before taking a mark that also caused uproar.
The goal proved to be decisive with the Swans eventually rushing a behind to win the contest.
Fans were left absolutely livid with the decision.
However, many argued that Moore lost his footing without much pressure.
That's an embarrassing call by the umpire. More cringey from papley to carry on after getting a goal from a soft free kick though. Bit like me fist pumping for getting a toy from a happy meal
— sassy (@sassy_goldfish) September 17, 2022
I’m 💔 but Swans deserved it. Proud of the Pies. Amazing year coming from 17th. Bloods always tough to beat.
(PS Would like to never, ever meet the umpire who didn’t see Papley’s hands in Darcy Moore’s back).— Peter Helliar (@pjhelliar) September 17, 2022
Push in the back or not, the ball is punched by an opposing player before Papley takes full control. So it shouldn’t have been paid a mark.
— michaelnotcera (@michaelnotcera1) September 17, 2022
As an independent to both teams, Swans got a dream ride off umpires including the clincher late with Papley pushing Moore in back and dropping mark. Home crowd is a massive influence for umpire decisions.
— Grant Thomas (@Thomo_Grant) September 17, 2022
Rugby league always carries on about refs costing teams the game - umpires totally cost Collingwood a grand final berth tonight. The Papley free kick for a goal just for a start, give me a spell
— Ben Dorries (@bendorries76) September 17, 2022
Comical. How about the bit where Papley drops the mark… what epically ridiculous take do you have on that?
— Record Spinna (@recordspinna) September 17, 2022
And Papley’s goal after he pushed Darcy Moore in the back and got gifted a free kick
— magpieliffy (@MagpieLiffy) September 17, 2022
I never like sooking about umpiring but that “mark” to Papley and missed free kick to Darcy Moore really hurts #AFLSwansPies 😣
— Andrew Stafford (@staffo_sez) September 17, 2022
#BREAKING - Tom Papley makes AFL history by pushing Darcy Moore in the back 3 times in the one marking contest. #AFLSwansPies
— Paul Zauch (@PaulZauch) September 17, 2022
Papley joined the Channel 7 team after the match and was asked about the incident.
"Looks like you gave him a little bit of a shove, 'Paps. To get Darcy Moore out underneath the footy, were you a bit nervous?" he was asked.
Papley showed his cheeky side.
"Nah, just a bit of forward-craft," Papley joked.
Sydney Swans make AFL grand final in thriller
Sydney's only other preliminary final at the SCG was a one-point win over Essendon in 1996 - the start of the Swans' current era that has featured two premierships and now seven grand final appearances.
"I'm OK - it's just a prelim final by a point," coach John Longmire deadpanned post-match.
The Cats will start favourites next Saturday, particularly given they cruised to a 71-point win over Brisbane, they have the extra day to prepare while Sydney and Collingwood belted the hell out of each other to the death.
But Longmire said the Swans will be ready.
"We'll be OK. It was a pretty tough blowout, right to the last two seconds. We covered it well, we'll be OK," he said.
The Magpies, who have become the AFL's cardiac kids this season with a string of close wins, looked shot in the third term when they fell six goals behind.
But they kicked four goals to one in the last quarter to nearly do it again.
Coach Craig McRae left his players alone post-match for a few minutes, saying he was worried his emotions would get the better of him.
"It's difficult, because you get so close. There's just an overwhelming sense of pride, though.
"You look at the players in the eye and see how much they hurt and see how much they've given for the year, to fall short.
Luke Parker subdued Collingwood star Jordan De Goey in a best-afield performance, while captain Scott Pendlebury and fellow onballer Jack Crisp were outstanding for the Magpies.
Lance Franklin kicked two first-half goals for the Swans, taking him to equal-third for AFL goals in finals
"What a finish. Wow. Well done to our boys. They fought really hard. They were a really good team. We knew they were going to come and they did," Franklin said.
"It felt longer than 30 seconds (at the end), that's for sure."
Swans key position player Sam Reid was subbed off at the start of the third term with an adductor injury, putting him in serious doubt for the grand final.
with AAP
Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.