'This is embarrassing': AFL world erupts over 'awful' farce

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
·Sports Editor
·4-min read
In this article:
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
Chris Scott, pictured here spraying umpire Ray Chamberlain at half-time.
Chris Scott sprayed umpire Ray Chamberlain at half-time. Image: Channel 7

Port Adelaide’s win over Geelong in their AFL qualifying final has been overshadowed by controversy surrounding the standard of umpiring.

Steven Motlop kicked three goals as Port recorded a 16-point win over Geelong on Thursday night.

HOT WATER: Jesse Hogan charged over 'female visitor'

‘HOW GOOD’: Footy fans flip out over 'insane' photo

The Power prevailed 9.4 (58) to 5.12 (42) at Adelaide Oval to secure a home preliminary final, continuing the Cats’ misery in finals.

While the standard of play had fans on the edge of their seats, the standard of umpiring left many seeing red.

A number of decisions confused both teams, with Geelong coach Chris Scott having words with the officials at half-time.

Scott could be seen yelling at umpire Ray Chamberlain, appearing to question why he was doing the centre bounces.

Chamberlain was performing each bounce from slightly left of the centre circle and wasn’t getting much height.

“You look at the position where the ball is actually being bounced,” Essendon great Jobe Watson said in commentary.

“The idea is you have a centre circle and both players get an even opportunity because the ball is getting bounced in the middle of the circle.

“If you take it to one side, you immediately disadvantage one of the teams, and so for equity if you can’t get it to bounce high in the middle, then the most sensible thing to do is to throw it up.”

Scott said he was merely enquiring about which umpire was bouncing the ball, rather than questioning their decision-making.

However other commentators and fans did.

“The “if you know who’s umpiring, he’s probably doing a bad job” rule in full effect tonight,” Richard Hinds wrote on Twitter.

Others described the umpiring as “embarrassing” and “awful”.

Geelong facing sudden death clash

Geelong are now tossed into sudden-death mode: a semi-final awaits against the winner of Saturday night's elimination final between West Coast and Collingwood.

Ex-Cat Motlop tormented his former side, kicking goals with his initial three kicks in a brutal final which Port cracked open in the third term.

After leading by one-point at half-time, the Power slotted three goals in a match-defining 15-minute burst which created a 19-point advantage.

The nearest Geelong crept thereafter was seven points early in the last quarter.

“We were pretty ruthless in the third quarter when we got a little bit of a gap on them,” Port coach Ken Hinkley said after his club's first finals win since 2014.

“We dominated that quarter ... and in finals it's a big margin when you get to 14 or 15 points up because you know how hard it is to score.”

Port Adelaide players, pictured here celebrating a goal as Gary Ablett looks on.
Power players celebrate as Gary Ablett of the Cats looks on during the AFL First Qualifying Final. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Port were superbly served by a battle-hardened core of Ollie Wines (24 disposals), Travis Boak (22), Tom Rockliff (22), Robbie Gray (17), Ebert (16, two goals) and Hamish Hartlett (15).

Geelong's Coleman medallist Tom Hawkins was goal-less and wayward, kicking 0.5 - a year after he kicked 0.4 in a qualifying final loss to Collingwood.

“We could have played better, there's no doubt about that, and Port were good,” Scott said.

“They deserved their win but I didn't think we were without our chances.”

Ruckman Rhys Stanley scored two majors while Brandan Parfitt (16 disposals), Brownlow medallist Patrick Dangerfield (22 touches, one goal), Mitch Duncan (19 possessions) and Sam Menegola (18 touches) had prominent patches.

But their feats weren’t enough to stop the Cats sliding to a 12th loss from their past 16 finals.

Port’s victory came at a cost with winger Xavier Duursma knocked out and young forward Todd Marshall hurting a shoulder.

with AAP

Click here to sign up to our newsletter for all the latest and breaking stories from Australia and around the world.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting