On the newest episode of Backstage's In the Envelope: The Actor's Podcast, casting director Eric Dawson — who has worked with AHS creator Ryan Murphy since the late 1990s — reminisced on the Barbie star's audition for the horror anthology.
"Margot has a lot of 'it' factors. That's the tough thing for casting directors who aren't in the room [anymore] with actors. Margot is probably one of my favorite auditions of all time, and it was right before she broke out," Dawson said of Robbie, who would go on to have a breakout role in 2013's The Wolf of Wall Street instead.
He continued, "She was such a star. It was crazy, her star appeal when she walked in the room. Even though she didn't get that role, that was one of those things as a casting director where you go: This is a star, what do we do with her?"
Kristina Bumphrey/Variety via Getty Images Margot Robbiie
Dawson explained that it immediately became clear "she was out of our realm of possibility of hiring" though he didn't elaborate as to why. However, he added, "That's really the fun part of casting, is seeing the people whose careers are just rising."
Though the casting veteran didn't reveal which part Robbie was up for, Asylum — which is widely considered to be a fan-favorite season — ultimately starred Zachary Quinto, Joseph Fiennes, Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Lily Rabe, Lizzie Brocheré, James Cromwell, Jessica Lange, and more.
The series, which is gearing up to debut its 12th season, Delicate, on Sept. 20, has oft served as a launching (or re-launching) pad for major talent over the years. Lady Gaga famously landed her first major acting role in American Horror Story: Hotel, for which she won a Golden Globe.
Sign up for Entertainment Weekly's free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.