7Sports app

Cronulla fined $1 million, coach Shane Flanagan banned over supplements program

AAP Updated December 17, 2013, 1:07 pm

The Cronulla Sharks have been hit with a proposed $1 million fine and their coach Shane Flanagan provisionally suspended for 12 months, as the NRL took a heavy hand to the club's controversial 2011 supplement program.

NRL chief executive Dave Smith said the club had failed many of the players in regards to safeguarding their health and welfare, adding that they were exposed to significant potential risk.

Former Cronulla strength and conditioning coach Trent Elkin, who now works for Parramatta, has also had his registration provisionally cancelled.

Smith said $400,000 of the proposed $1 million fine would be suspended if the club met a series of conditions.

He added Flanagan's suspension may be shortened to nine months if he undertook further education and training.

"Information of a serious nature has been presented, and following a thorough and rigorous assessment, I have formed a preliminary view that the club is in breach of the rules and that action needs to be taken with respect to the registrations of two individuals," Smith said.

Smith said ASADA's investigation is still ongoing and as such, no infraction notices have been handed down to players.

He stressed the NRL's findings were provisional, and the Sharks as well as Flanagan and Elkin would have a chance to respond before punishments are confirmed.

The provisional view of the NRL is that Flanagan and Elkin failed in their duty of care to players, putting the athletes at risk and exposing them to possible violations of the game's anti-doping code.

Smith said no other Cronulla officials or training staff had a case to answer.

The major players will now have a chance to reply, and an appeal process is in place.

"This has been a very, very thorough process," Smith said.

"All parties now have the chance to put their case forward.

Smith says the health of Cronulla's players had been put at risk. Source: Getty

"We've worked through this over a number of months and I spoke to Cronulla this morning and to Shane.

"It's a difficult situation and I encouraged him to put his submission forward and we would make sure any support we can give him and his family we would be right there with him. But quite clearly it's a very difficult set of circumstances. If provisional findings are upheld - player welfare and wellbeing is front and centre of considerations we make."

Cronulla have been in the sights of ASADA for the alleged use of illegal peptides, since the drugs in sport investigation was announced by the Australian Crime Commission on February 7.

In March, the Sharks launched an investigation into happenings at the club in the 2011 season, which was overseen by sports scientist Stephen Dank.

Flanagan was stood down by the Sharks, along with four other staff members, however he was reinstated on March 22 following a second review by a different consultancy group.

However, Flanagan is set to have no involvement with the Sharks' 2014 season, with Brett Kimmorley in line to take over the reins as coach.

The NRL's actions against Cronulla aren't dissimilar to punishments handed down from the AFL to Essendon for their supplement program.

Coach James Hird was ousted for a year and the club hit with a $2 million sanction.

"It's a very complex set of circumstances for both codes," said Smith.

"We have followed a fair process, didn't overreact in any shape or form, and taken everything into consideration.

"Any comparison with AFL is inevitable but it's not a route we've followed.

"We owe our fans and players that we follow a transparent process whereby we act when we have the facts and make sure people have the opportunity to present their side as well."

Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies


  1. wan06:38am Wednesday 18th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse

    Cronulla use drugs...fined $1m...Johns uses drugs...made a highly paid face of the game on national TV???

  2. Big Kev 13309:34pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse

    Same as Essendon so for the people who aren't aware of how the law is supposed to operate, read on. No facts or prosecution has yet been forwarded by ASADA but the NRL has already said that Sharks are GUILTY and have proposed a $1 million fine for the club plus banned Flanigan from coaching for a year. What in hell ever happened to due process. Get some facts together ( real facts not just media stories ) then after that you bring down the guilty parties and thats when you doink them with the penalties. Could any of you imagine this in a real court of law.

    1 Reply
  3. Wally08:09pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse

    Why haven't they been stripped of points like Storm?

  4. FISHO06:53pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse


  5. FISHO06:52pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse


  6. FISHO06:52pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse


  7. FISHO06:51pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse


  8. FISHO06:51pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse


  9. Dave06:20pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse

    In 2011 was the supplements on the banned list, if so fare enough if they were not then how can it be a crime now. My understanding is ASADA has no authority to issue fines and suspension only to investigate, it is the NRL who hands down the punishment

  10. Sportslover06:19pm Tuesday 17th December 2013 ESTReport Abuse

    A million dollars fine is hardly a slap on the wrist, particularly when it comes to the salary cap (in itself an NRL joke). However, before Cronulla takes the field next season ALL it's financial dealings including ALL players/officials salaries must be audited by the NRL auditors.