Watters blames Carlton for spiteful match

Sportal September 2, 2012, 8:56 pm
Scott Watters

Getty Images © Enlarge photo

St Kilda coach Scott Watters has blamed Carlton for a spiteful final round clash at Etihad Stadium, suggesting the emotion of the last week got the better of the Blues' players.

Although it may have been a dead rubber between two sides that both narrowly missed the finals, there was no shortage of nastiness as the two teams traded blows throughout an encounter that St Kilda eventually won by 15 points.

Before the match even began, Carlton's Andrew Walker and Saint Stephen Milne were engaged in a heated wrestle that saw the pair reported within 15 seconds of the opening bounce.

There will be plenty of other incidents assessed by the match review panel on Monday as Milne (first quarter elbow on Ed Curnow) along with Carlton's Eddie Betts (second quarter elbow on David Armitage) and Mitch Robinson (first quarter bump on Leigh Montagna) will all have incidents looked at.

And Watters himself wasn't pulling any punches in his post-match press conference, saying an emotional week where Carlton coach Brett Ratten was sacked may have played a part in the fiery encounter.

"There was obviously a bit of emotion in the game I think at different times," declared Watters.

"It was probably more emotional than a few games I've seen them play, but that doesn't really bother me as a coach and it shouldn't bother our players, we need to be able to handle that.

"There were some efforts that I saw from them today that I hadn't seen from them in a few weeks, so maybe that was brought about by the events, but our job's to focus on what we need to do, so I thought our players generally held their nerve pretty well."

Although Watters refused to mention the incidents that concerned him he could not resist having a go at Carlton's defenders and particularly Walker for the close attention paid to Milne.

"I guess what does probably amaze me and I will say this is, do forwards often wrestle with defenders? Do forwards often target defenders? I don't think so. It's generally the other way around."

Watters said he didn't blame Milne for losing his focus a little.

"He's only human," declared Watters.

"Cops a fair bit of attention, Milney.

"At times I question how much he's protected."

But when asked whether his players had been overly physical in the contest, Ratten threw the blame back at St Kilda.

"Please," declared an incredulous Ratten.

"Have a look at behind the goals," Ratten added. "Rhys O'Keefe got picked off the ball 30 metres away.

"If he wants to talk about all that stuff, I think the review panel will have a very good day at dissecting that.

"There's a couple of ways to take confrontation, isn't there?

"You back down and cower or you meet the challenge head on and I suppose depending on what resistance you get back is how hard you push back physically and I don't think there was punches thrown.

"So the umpires will pick through that.

"(But) St Kilda have probably had the wood on Carlton for a few years and this was an opportunity to maybe go into a fresh season with maybe a victory over them and I thought, to the boys' credit, they pushed really hard to get that result."

Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies


  1. greg04:24pm Monday 03rd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    While i think the Carlton players let Ratts down this year with lazy selfish efforts, Watters is kidding isnt he? Milne is a grub, always has been and always will be. Hey Milne, you cant point to the scoreboard all you want, but number of premiership medals you have, ZERO. moron

  2. underarm_bowler01:07pm Monday 03rd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Operation mangle Milne. I'll give $50 to charity for any player that knocks him out and an even hundred for any player that rapes him during the game

    1 Reply
  3. Meatloaf10:01am Monday 03rd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Milne is a dirty dog and the sooner someone smashes him the better.

  4. nicky07:22am Monday 03rd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    watters get your head out your #$%$ milne and montagna are rapist filth i cant wait to see milne get his head knocked off

  5. daveyblue2000@yahoo.com.au07:13am Monday 03rd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    One has to ask the question of this Carlton playing group; where has your passion and ticker been for the best part of the season? Pathetic! Reaally PATHETIC effort

  6. trev11:44pm Sunday 02nd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    C'mon Watters Carlton wouldn't do anything out of the rules - just ask Captain Chicken Wing !

  7. d09:55pm Sunday 02nd September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Nah Watters, Milne's mouth never starts anything. Take your rose coloured glasses off.