Cloke saga a burden on Pies

Russell Robertson August 22, 2012, 10:46 am

The ongoing saga between the Magpies, Travis Cloke and those teams coming up with the big bucks to nab him has become tiresome and no doubt a burden.

There has been a great deal of outcry from the members and even the hierarchy look to be jack of it!

I would fathom a guess that the Collingwood faithful are not particularly a bunch whose emotions like to be played with.

The party line for players like Travis in the lucky position to negotiate has been: I will wait till the end of the season before I make any decisions about my AFL future.

It may be a lucky position in a financial sense but as a player, when everything you do is devoted to preparing yourself for the best performance every weekend, having an uncertain future surely must hinder that process. And if it hinders one player, so fine and unstable is an AFL club environment, it can have a wide-reaching effect.

I was never that lucky in my career to have a seven figure sum offered to me as bait to join another club. I ask myself regularly now, as it is becoming pretty common place for the league's finest these days, what would I have done if presented with the opportunity.

In 2007 I was courted by the Western Bulldogs, to play for a great deal more than I was on and for three years, one more than what Melbourne were offering. I decided to stay at Melbourne for my own reasons but mostly because I needed the assurance of my future and to stay with what I knew. I felt more comfortable and played better as a result.

I look back now and ponder the decision as Melbourne eventually parted ways with me after two years in a rebuilding phase where as if I had jumped ship I'd have had another year of pay at the Doggies. In all my meandering though I always reach the same conclusion, money is not everything and legacy is.

What Travis Cloke effectively is doing at the moment is holding out for money. His market value is peaking and it's time to cash in on that good form.

Now, we cannot scorn him for this. Any reasonable working man or woman on the planet, if offered twice their wage to do the same job elsewhere, would not think twice. But sometimes, in rare circumstances like this, money should really be a secondary thought.

I am intensely proud of my decision to be a one-club player. Oh, sure I could be better off now. I could have a bigger TV or a nicer car.

What I have instead is the pride in the knowledge that I turned down all of that to go through my life knowing I gave something greater than just my efforts on the field to my football club.

Melbourne is my football club. Not Melbourne and the Bulldogs. I wore the red and the blue like Ron Barassi and Norm Smith before me. I did not have the ideal ending to my career but that is quickly forgotten because there is infinite pride to staying with one club, something you will only come to know once you retire and can no longer affect that legacy.

I think back and it was more than the goals and the marks, more than the grand times on and off the field with my mates, and more than the glitzy shining lights and trimmings that come with being a league footballer - I think of that fact, I was a Demon.

Clokie has a decision to make and rest assured it will be one that follows him for the rest of his life. He won't get that yet, but he will eventually.

So, will he be a superstar Collingwood icon like Tony Shaw and Bob Rose, or will he be a great player from a couple of clubs with a really big TV?

My tips:
Essendon, St Kilda, Brisbane, Sydney, Collingwood, Carlton, Geelong, North Melbourne, Adelaide

Oldest First
Newest First
Top Rated
Most Replies


  1. Meatloaf12:22pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Mmmm the tigers next year. Fevola full forward Cloke centre half forward and jacky boy on the forward flank. All we need now is a decent back line.

  2. Jas R12:35pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Unfortunately staying as a 1 club player on less money doesn't pay the bils when he retires and has injuries that restrict his employment options. He may not want that extra big TV - but he may want a better security for his kids and family in his later years. No-one remembers the one club players for being that - they remember the players for being a champion - I would remember Gary Ablett Junior as a champion over Tony Shaw or 95% of other players to have ever played the game. Every worker in the modern age moves for the $$ in all industries. Collingwood wont care about Travis if he stays, and when he is 60 and in financial strain. What will they do??? nothing, it is his problem. They should offer him what the rest of the market is - otherwise they are just slapping him in the face. Robbo - it sounds like you also wished you took the Bulldogs deal, because you mention that you were disappointed that Melb let you go after the 2 years - were you expecting an extension?? if you moved you would have got that extra year and money. No-one remembers you for being a 1 club player.. Just for your high grabs.

  3. david12:51pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    You're welcome to the selfish mercenary Meatloaf. All the best with your offer, it will be one time in my life I'm barracking for the Tigers to have a 'win'! Trav's selfishness has already cost him a 'legacy' at Collingwood, so good riddance to bad rubbish

  4. Pippa Middleton01:21pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I have been watching cloke and dawes play and if i was their coach, the two would have been dropped to the VFL eight weeks ago to sort out their #$%$ Why cloke would think he's worth more money has me in fits of laughter, i would love him at The Mighty Tigers but he would have to improve with his kicking and marking 500% for the money he wants.

  5. Daggers01:30pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I'm sick of hearing about it & hope the greed brings him undone.

  6. mr01:41pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    who really cares where he goes he is only following his dads directions. He is no Buddy Franklin just another footballer of average ability with average skills so may I suggest he go to the Gold Coast or Western Sydney but oops Dad would not be there to look after him, but they be able to teach him to kick and mark to keep his average skills up. Tatata

  7. Ozblueboy01:49pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    By the way Robbo, both Norm Smith ( Fitzroy/Melbourne ) & Ron Barassi ( Carlton/Melbourne ) were 2 team players.

  8. Meatloaf02:04pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I was only joking david or did you miss the part about fevola. The tigers would be stupid to recruit him after all the work they have done to get out of debt. Its nice to dream though. Its been a long 30 years or so.

  9. underarm_bowler04:37pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Offload him to Carlton.that's where most of our hacks usually go

  10. Anthony04:53pm Wednesday 22nd August 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I remember once - i was walking along the road and stopped - i smelled the flowers........ They were nice...... And then i walked some more.